Underwriting
1-866-ARF-MEOW

Chew on This: 2022’s Most Indestructible Dog Toys

Written By
14 min read

Updated - Apr 5th, 2022

While some dogs are gentle with their beloved stuffed animals, colorful rope toys, bouncy balls, or chew toys, others are not. Let’s face it: a dog’s animal instincts can lead them to conquer – and to decimate. For you, it can be distressing to present your furry friend with a toy only to find that, within mere minutes, it’s been ripped to shreds, leaving stuffing and fabric for the custodial clean-up crew (a.k.a you). Luckily, a few admirable pet toy companies have generated materials, stitching techniques, and other innovations that can stand up against even the most aggressive chewers. 

There are a wide variety of the toughest dog toys on the market – from bones to plush toys to chew toys – that can provide your dog with maximum playtime, while reducing the risk of getting destroyed and ending up in your dog’s digestive system. Regardless of the breed, gender, or size, any dog can potentially be a repeat toy-destroyer; but the good news is you can find toys that are as close to indestructible as possible.  

What makes a good toy good? 

While your dog may seem content playing with a stick they discovered on your morning walk, an old tennis ball found in your garage, or an unlucky squirrel that couldn’t escape fast enough, durable dog toys are more sustainable, better for your dog’s overall health, and definitely worth the extra money. 

Richard Lovejoy, a dog trainer based out of Brooklyn, NY, believes that indestructible dog chew toys are essential to your dog’s happiness, and provide additional benefits as well. He points out: “It’s important to be considerate even beyond the scope of the dog’s health. It’s always good to think sustainably.” Investing in toys that might be more expensive, but are proven to last longer, will reduce waste and eliminate the cost of having to replace toys often. Lovejoy encourages dog owners to “be as responsible as you can in the arenas that you can be responsible.” 

Aside from finding a dog toy that’s indestructible, there are a few other features you should consider before gifting your pup with something shiny and new: 

  • Versatility: You use a ball to play fetch, a rope to play tug-of-war, and a bone for chewing. But what if you could find a toy that serves multiple purposes? A lot of interactive dog toys on the market today can provide your dog with multiple forms of play. If it can be fetched, it might also be tugged or chewed on heavily. Finding a toy that serves several purposes will give your dog long-lasting entertainment, which reduces boredom and can keep your dog on their best behavior. As humans, we often want things that are worth the money spent on them; dog toys fall under this category, as well. 
  • Health benefits: Dog toys offer tons of health benefits to our furry friends. Chewing on toys has been proven to relieve stress, reduce anxiety, fulfill the dog’s instinctual needs, and promote dental health. Plus, it’s perfect for teething puppies. Chewing on the right kind of rubber can remove plaque buildup and stimulate gums, which improves the overall health of your dog’s mouth. Dental hygiene is super important for your dog and can prevent things like dental disease, tooth loss, and even organ damage from bad bacteria entering your dog’s bloodstream through their mouths. 
  • Materials: If you can’t pronounce the name of the type of plastic used on your dog’s toy, there’s a fair chance that the material isn’t ideal for them. Looking for toys that are made from 100% natural, food-grade rubber or fabric is essential for making sure your dog won’t accidentally ingest harmful materials and chemicals. No toy is completely indestructible, but some of them come pretty close; but you want to make sure that on the off chance that your dog is able to break off a few chunks, they’ll be able to pass it with no complications. The materials that are good for your dog are also more likely to be good for the environment, so it’s a win/win for all! 

Now that we’ve laid out some of the basics of purchasing dog toys, it’s time to get started. Here is Pumpkin’s ultimate guide to 2021’s best indestructible dog toys, including all you need to know about their features, prices – and most importantly – their durability.

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links at no additional cost to you. We may earn commissions from Amazon or other vendors through these links. As an Amazon Associate, Pumpkin earns commissions from qualifying purchases.

1. Outward Hound Invincibles Dog Toy – Stuffingless Squeaky Plush Dog Toy 

This multi-purpose toy is double seamed and double lined for double the fun – and life span. The inner Dura-Tuff lining is reinforced with double stitching, which makes it the ultimate challenge for a power chewer to successfully pierce through and attempt to destroy. There’s no stuffing, so you won’t have to worry about finding scraps of cotton scattered across your carpet. Instead, they come with multiple squeakers that satisfy your dog’s crunching needs and optimize fun – only at the sake of your eardrums. The squeakers maintain the toy’s softness, so your dog won’t have to sacrifice cuddliness for durability. The toy comes in three different sizes, so you can choose the right one based on the size of your pup (and/or the size your pup thinks they are), and comes in multiple fun animal designs. It’s perfect for tugging, tossing, or just plain chewing. It’s also really affordable, so in the unfortunate case that your canine does destroy it, at least it didn’t burn a hole in your pocket and can be easily replaced if desired.

 

2. NOUGAT Dog Toys For Aggressive Chewers

Made of 100% eco-friendly, natural, and non-toxic BPA-free rubber, this toy has both your dog’s playing and health needs in mind. This toy is aimed towards medium to large dogs and has been tested against German Shepherds, Labradors, and other large dogs. While no toy is completely indestructible, it comes really close and offers more benefits aside from being super chewable. Complete with bristles, it provides a safe and fun way for your dog to clean its teeth whenever they play. For added hygiene, you can squeeze dog toothpaste into the grooves of the bristles, so your dog will essentially be brushing their own teeth while playing. This removes plaque, tartar, and helps stimulate gums. It also has a natural milk flavor which will entice your dog to want to play with it even more. It also contains a squeaker which will encourage your dog to play and keep their interest for long periods of time. It’s easy to clean with soap and water, which adds to its longevity and will help solidify it as your dog’s go-to chew toy for years to come.  

3. Apasiri Dog Chew Toy

This chew toy is made of natural, durable rubber and food-grade nylon – and has passed more than 1,000 bite tests against aggressive chewers. This dog bone is designed for medium to large sized dogs, and it’s almost indestructible. Since it’s made of nylon, it’s possible that pieces will fall apart with excessive chewing, but the safe rubber will pass through the digestive system easily without impacting your dog. The unique rubber spikes in the center of the toy provide cleaning for your dog’s teeth as they chew. They’re able to fit between teeth as a sort of flossing tool, removing bad bacteria and improving dental health. This toy is also perfect for teething puppies. It’s beef flavored, making it a yummy and enticing toy for your dog to safely enjoy for multiple play options. It can be used as a fetch toy and prhttps://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B08F5G6CGN/ref=as_li_tl?ie=UTF8&camp=1789&creative=9325&creativeASIN=B08F5G6CGN&linkCode=as2&tag=pumpkinpetcar-20&linkId=553ffa2da144a1ae97da124c6573a655ovides dogs with interactive play that will keep them focused and busy. It can be easily hand washed, so you won’t have to throw it away once it starts getting dirty. You can just clean it up and give it back to your pup! 

4. Arm & Hammer Super Treadz Chew Toy for Dogs

This extremely durable, all-natural rubber chew toy is designed with your dogs playtime and dental needs in mind. It contains grooves that help clean your dog’s teeth by stimulating their gums and removing plaque buildup. Infused with baking soda, it freshens your dog’s breath safely and gently. It comes in two shapes: gator and gorilla; so it’s guaranteed for maximum fun that’s sure to distract your pup for long periods of time. This toy is also inexpensive, which makes it less devastating if it gets destroyed and makes it easy to replace. As an added bonus, it’s dishwasher safe for easy cleaning. You might as well just buy two at checkout!

5. Willie Bones Modern Dog Chew Toy

Willie Bones are made with 100% natural rubber that is non-toxic, BPA free, and Phthalate free. The modern design of these toys contains ridges and multiple sides to create dimension and allow for more chewing fun. They’re also designed

to be the perfect size for small, medium, and large breeds, so you don’t have to worry about purchasing the right size. The durable technology allows for hours of chewing, which improves your pup’s dental health, relieves stress and anxiety, and reduces boredom. This toy can be played with both on land and in the water. It bounces and floats easily, so you can toss this to your dog in your backyard or in the pool! If you’re still questioning the durability of this toy, take it from Salena, the owner of two Mini Dachshunds with very sharp teeth. She writes that they’ve been able to rip their Kongs and Nylabones to shreds, but this toy has survived their wrath with just a few minor battle scars. This toy stands up to even the most extreme chewers! 

6. Chew King Supreme Fetch Balls

Regular tennis balls and rubber balls are no match for a repeat toy destroyer. But these Chew King balls are made of solid, natural rubber that’s durable, bouncy, and retains its shape without giving off any rubber or chemical scents. On top of being a dog ball perfect for a game of fetch, it also has a hole in the middle which serves as an air vent that can also be used to hide dog treats. Your dog can occupy their time with the treat dispensing, without you having to worry about them destroying the ball in the process. One buyer, J.W., wrote that they have a one-year-old Pit Bull and a 10-month-old Pyrenees/Lab mix –  a pair of breeds known for being fanatic chewers. J.W. notes that in the past year, these dogs have chewed a corner of a couch, six pairs of shoes, and part of a wall. But they finally met their match with these heavy-duty Chew King Supreme Fetch Balls, which they have yet to destroy.  


7. Sugelary Squeaky Dog Toys for Aggressive Chewer

This pineapple-shaped chew toy is perfect for meeting your dog’s instinctual chewing needs and satisfy their boredom. It can be used for fetching, tug-of-war, or just some good old fashioned chewing. High quality, natural food-grade rubber allows your fur baby to stay safe while chewing, ensuring that if it somehow manages to rip off a piece of the toy, it won’t hurt them. This toy has been tested against German Shepherds, Mastiffs, Siberian Huskies, Labradors, Golden Retrievers, Pit Bulls, and other well-known chewers and has been determined to be a great toy for aggressive chewers. It also comes complete with a squeaker, which is a must for any dog toy. 


8. goDog Dragon

These goDog toys are a staple in the realm of tough dog toys. As mentioned above repeatedly, no toy is indestructible, but this one truly does get as close as possible. It’s made with special chew guard technology that’s proven to outlast standard dog plush toys, but the goDog might not be able to stand up to the most aggressive of chewers. This squeaky toy has a squeaker located in the middle, and is covered by a high quality, textured bubble that will attract your dog while also protecting the squeaker from your dog’s sharp teeth. The limbs of the toy dangle down which also creates an irresistible tug-toy opportunity. The chew resistant lining and reinforced seams allow it to survive at least a little longer than the average toy. If it doesn’t, the company will provide you with a refund. The most inviting thing about this toy is that it is very soft and plushy. Some “indestructible” plush dog toys are hard and a little too tough, which isn’t always what your dog is looking for. This toy doesn’t sacrifice being cuddly in order to be heavy-duty – something that can probably be said about your dog, too! 


9. TUFFY— World’s Tuffest Soft Dog Toy

This toy is built for playing – tossing, tugging, and chasing – rather than straight up chewing, but it’s been tested against aggressive chewers and is proven to be suitable for them. It’s lined with up to four layers of fabric and is stitched together with up to 7 rows of stitching. A protective webbing on the outside edges covers the seams, making them even more difficult for your dog’s teeth to pierce through. Squeakers are sewn inside of protective pouches, ensuring your dog will have a difficult time getting to them. If they are able to access the protective pouch, it buys you some time to retrieve the toy from your dog before they attempt to swallow any of the squeakers. It can also float in water and is machine washable! This warthog shaped toy comes in two colors and one standard size that’s suitable for both small dogs and big dogs. 


10. Outward Hound Fire Biterz

The Outward Hound Fire Biterz toys are made from actual fire hose material – yes, you read that right! These plush toys are made from tightly-woven rubber fibers of fire hose material and a K9 Tuff guard lining for longer periods of play. This toy is built for play rather than for chewing, but should last your pup longer than the average plush toy. They also include the company’s signature Invincibles Squeakers that keep squeaking even if your dog succeeds at puncturing it. There’s also no stuffing inside the toy so if your dog does manage to rip it to shreds, there’s less mess and less material for your dog to ingest. It’s not the cuddliest of toys, but the inner squeakers provide some plushiness, and the long, lanky design of the toy makes it perfect for playing tug-of-war. These toys come in three sizes and are available in ten adorable shapes. 


11. NEOROD Durable Dog Chew Toy

This dumbbell shaped toy is ideal for your dog to grip onto and hold while chewing. It has hollow areas which are perfect for stuffing your dog’s favorite treats or food sprays, allowing for hours of fun with a nice reward at the end! Chewing on a toy like this and figuring out how to access the food within the ridges can enhance your dog’s intelligence, reduce anxiety, and help improve dental health. It’s made of high density, natural rubber that has been tested against Pit Bulls, German Shepherds, and more. This food-grade, natural, and raw rubber is non-toxic and environmentally friendly, making it safe for your dog to chew on for long periods of time. One reviewer, Jenny, is the owner of a 9-year-old Pit Bull and says this is the only toy that has ever lasted longer than three days. While this Pittie might be frustrated that she can’t destroy it, it has definitely succeeded at keeping her busy! 


12. KUSSONLI Dog Chew Toys for Indestructible Aggressive Chewers

This skeleton shaped toy is ideal for any strong-jawed furry friend. The grooves and ridges are perfect for getting between your dog’s teeth to clean out any plaque and tartar buildup that might be causing your pet’s gums to deteriorate – and their breath to be unbearable! The rubber is non-toxic and safe, while maintaining an ideal balance between firmness and chewiness; it also has a milk flavor that will attract your dog to it and encourage chewing. The double-headed toy has a squeaker on each end, which will satisfy your dog’s instincts and encourage more play. The positive reviews include testimonials from owners of Siberian Huskies, Boxers, King Corsos, and more! 

It’s high time to say goodbye to the days of cleaning up after your dog’s latest victim – and to introduce your dog to a fairer, hardier match. These 12 dog toys – with their variety of shapes, firmness/softness levels, and added options of squeakers in some – are primed to stand the test of time…and of strong teeth. Whichever toy you purchase, rest assured that you’re choosing from a comprehensive list of dog toys designed to withstand your fur baby’s jaws of destruction, while keeping them healthy and happy. Nothing makes your four-legged friends, and you, happier than a little controlled carnage with a beloved plaything. 


For easy access to new toy purchasing, here’s a list of Amazon links to the 12 best indestructible dog toys of 2021:

  1. Outward Hound Invincibles Dog Toy – Stuffingless Squeaky Plush Dog Toy
  2. NOUGAT Dog Toys For Aggressive Chewers
  3. Apasiri Dog Chew Toy
  4. Arm & Hammer Super Treadz Chew Toy for Dogs
  5. Willie Bones Modern Dog Chew Toy
  6. Chew King Supreme Fetch Balls
  7. Sugelary Squeaky Dog Toys for Aggressive Chewer
  8. goDog Dragon
  9. TUFFY— World’s Tuffest Soft Dog Toy
  10.  Outward Hound Fire Biterz
  11. NEOROD Durable Dog Chew Toy
  12. KUSSONLI Dog Chew Toys for Indestructible Aggressive Chewers

Passionate Pet Experts & Parents
We are a team of writers, designers & product developers who all double as passionate (ok, obsessive) nerds of the pet world.

Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Cookies Policy

Scroll to Top
[class^="wpforms-"]
[class^="wpforms-"]